| Comparisons |
|
Donor Advised Fund |
|
Private Foundation |
| Creating the Foundation |
Established at SCF by a simple agreement |
Nonprofit corporation or trust organized as a private foundation |
| Tax Exempt Status |
Shares the public charity tax exempt status of SCF, as a “component” of SCF |
Must apply for private foundation tax exempt status from the IRS |
| Start-up Costs |
No cost to donor |
Similar to a corporate start-up requiring substantial legal, accounting, and operational start-up costs |
| Recommended Size |
$10,000 or more |
Substantial assets required |
Charitable Deductions for Cash Gifts |
Tax deduction of up to 50% of adjusted gross income (AGI) |
Tax deduction of up to 30% of adjusted gross income (AGI) |
| Charitable Deductions for Appreciated Property |
Tax deduction available for full fair market value of marketable securities and other property |
Tax deduction may be taken for fair market value of marketable securities up to 20% of AGI. Tax deduction for other property is limited to the lower of cost or fair market value |
| Donor Control |
Donor makes advisory grant recommendations; final decision rests with SCF’s board of directors |
Donor retains complete control over investments and grant making, subject to IRS requirements |
| Self-Dealing Rules |
Private foundation self-dealing rules do not apply |
Strict regulations prohibit most transactions between a private foundation and its donors (including related persons or organizations) |
| Payout Requirements |
Do not apply |
Must pay out for charitable purposes at least 5% of its asset value annually, regardless of its income |
| Administrative Concerns(personnel, facility, gift, and grant managing) |
Services provided by SCF |
Must establish and/or obtain these services |
| Annual Costs |
Minimal |
Administration can be costly |
| Annual Taxes |
None |
Subject to an excise tax of up to 2% of net investment gain, including net capital gains and income |
| Annual Tax Filings and Returns (990 Report) |
Not required (reported as part of SCF’s annual reporting) |
Must be filed by the private foundation with required reporting schedules |
| Investments |
Fund assets are professionally invested through SCF’s investment program |
Must research, secure, and carefully monitor its own investment vehicles |
| Fiduciary Responsibility |
SCF fulfills the associated fiduciary responsibilities |
The private foundation board has fiduciary responsibility |
| Liability and Risk Insurance |
Provided by SCF |
Must be purchased by the private foundation |